The recent unveiling of Book Riot’s “Best of the Century So Far” selections for young adult literature has sparked considerable discussion within literary circles. The rigorous process of curating a definitive list of 45 influential titles from the past 25 years, acknowledging the immense volume of exceptional YA works, necessitated difficult choices. While the final compilation represents a significant achievement in identifying seminal works, it also leaves many equally deserving titles on the periphery. This article delves into the meticulous selection methodology employed by Book Riot and highlights a selection of these critically acclaimed, yet ultimately unlisted, young adult novels that have profoundly shaped the genre.

The Deliberative Process Behind a Definitive List

The creation of Book Riot’s "Best of the Century So Far" list for young adult literature was an extensive undertaking, reflecting the dynamic and ever-expanding landscape of the genre. The editorial team and a dedicated cohort of contributors engaged in a multi-stage nomination and deliberation process. Each participant submitted their top picks, with titles receiving multiple nominations naturally ascending to the forefront of consideration. Subsequent rounds involved evaluating single nominations, ensuring a broad spectrum of voices, narratives, and perspectives.

Crucially, the selection criteria extended beyond mere popularity or critical acclaim. The team aimed for a holistic representation of YA literature, encompassing fiction, nonfiction, and graphic novels. This commitment to diversity in form and content was paramount. The iterative review process involved critically assessing the existing selections, identifying any perceived gaps, and considering whether certain titles could be more representative of a specific author’s oeuvre, stylistic innovation, genre contribution, or thematic importance within YA. Decisions regarding multiple submissions from a single author required careful negotiation to ensure the inclusion of their most impactful work. This deliberate and often challenging process underscores the complexity of identifying and honoring the most significant contributions to young adult literature.

Titles That Almost Made the Cut: A Glimpse into the Cutting Room Floor

The following titles, while not included in the final "Best of the Century So Far" list, are recognized for their substantial influence and enduring impact on the young adult literary landscape. They represent a fraction of the works that were extensively discussed and considered, each possessing unique qualities that resonate with readers and critics alike. Their inclusion on this supplementary list serves as a testament to their merit and encourages continued exploration of the rich tapestry of YA literature.

Allegedly by Tiffany D. Jackson

Tiffany D. Jackson has established herself as a formidable voice in contemporary young adult literature, and her debut novel, Allegedly, stands as a prime example of her impactful storytelling. Published in 2017, the novel plunges readers into a complex psychological thriller centered on Mary, a young woman whose childhood is marked by a harrowing accusation: she allegedly killed a baby at the age of nine. Six years later, on the cusp of motherhood, Mary begins to reclaim fragmented memories, forcing her to confront the truth of that fateful night.

Allegedly is lauded for its fast-paced narrative, which fearlessly tackles critical themes of race, the intricacies of the criminal justice system, social justice, mental health, and gender. The novel’s compelling voice, skillful plotting, and well-developed characters showcase Jackson’s exceptional talent, particularly for a debut work. The psychological depth and thematic exploration within Allegedly have cemented its status as a significant contribution to YA fiction. Jackson’s broader body of work, including Monday’s Not Coming, which was recognized on Book Riot’s “Best of the Century So Far: Mysteries/Thrillers” list, further solidifies her importance in the genre. Her ability to weave intricate plots with profound social commentary positions her as a consistently influential author.

The Battle of Jericho by Sharon Draper

Sharon Draper, a celebrated author with a long-standing presence in young adult literature, crafted The Battle of Jericho as the inaugural installment of her Jericho Trilogy, released in 2005. The novel introduces readers to 16-year-old Jericho, an aspiring athlete who receives an invitation to join the "Warriors of Distinction," an elite club within his school. The club promises social prestige, romantic attention, and academic success, all of which are particularly enticing to Jericho, especially when he begins to garner interest from Arielle.

However, as the pledging process intensifies, Jericho finds himself increasingly uncomfortable with the demands placed upon initiates and witnesses the harsh treatment of the sole female pledge. This internal conflict compels him to weigh his desire for acceptance and status within the school hierarchy against his growing moral convictions and the need to speak out against the injustices he observes. The Battle of Jericho is praised for its authentic portrayal of adolescent dilemmas, peer pressure, and the courage required to uphold one’s values. Draper’s extensive experience in writing for young adults is evident in her nuanced character development and relatable exploration of complex social dynamics. Her continued presence on influential book lists is a testament to her enduring legacy in the field.

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder by Holly Jackson

Holly Jackson’s A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, published in 2019, rapidly ascended to international bestseller status, captivating young adult readers with its intricate mystery and compelling protagonist. The novel centers on Pip, a high school senior who chooses the infamous murder case of Andie Bell and her boyfriend Sal Singh for her final project. Five years prior, Sal allegedly killed Andie before taking his own life, a narrative that has become the accepted truth in their town of Fairview. However, Pip harbors doubts, sensing inconsistencies that the official investigation overlooked.

As Pip delves deeper into the cold case, she uncovers dark secrets and hidden truths that challenge the established narrative, forcing her to confront the possibility that Sal may not have been the killer. The novel’s success is attributed to its clever plotting, authentic teenage voice, and the satisfying unraveling of the mystery. A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder has achieved significant crossover appeal, further amplified by its adaptation into popular media. Its inclusion on various "best of" lists highlights its impact on the resurgence of YA thrillers and its ability to engage a broad readership with sophisticated mystery elements.

Jack of Hearts (And Other Parts) by Lev A.C. Rosen

Lev A.C. Rosen’s Jack of Hearts (And Other Parts), released in 2020, is celebrated for its bold and boundary-pushing exploration of queer identity and adolescent sexuality. The novel follows Jack, a self-assured queer teenager who embraces his interest in sex. When he launches a sex-positive column for his school newspaper, he anticipates potential controversy but is unprepared for the intensity of the backlash. His candid and unapologetic writing style, while empowering for some, also attracts the attention of a stalker intent on silencing him.

The narrative centers on Jack’s quest, with the help of his friends, to identify and confront the stalker before any real harm can occur. The novel is lauded for its authentic and nuanced portrayal of a young queer protagonist, its frank discussions about sex and consent, and its exploration of the challenges faced by those who dare to be different. Jack of Hearts (And Other Parts) is recognized for its significant contribution to LGBTQ+ young adult literature, offering a refreshing and empowering perspective on adolescent self-discovery and the importance of speaking one’s truth.

Life As We Knew It by Susan Beth Pfeffer

Susan Beth Pfeffer’s Life As We Knew It, published in 2006, is a seminal work in the burgeoning genre of climate fiction and post-apocalyptic young adult literature. The novel presents a chilling hypothetical scenario: a meteor strikes the moon, altering its orbit and bringing it closer to Earth. This celestial event triggers a cascade of catastrophic consequences, including widespread natural disasters, power outages, and societal collapse. The story is told through the diary entries of Miranda, a high school student in a small Pennsylvania town, chronicling her family’s struggle for survival over the course of a year.

Life As We Knew It is distinguished by its intimate and immersive narrative style, offering a deeply personal perspective on a global crisis. The novel’s prescient exploration of themes such as resource scarcity, family resilience, and the psychological toll of living through widespread disaster resonates powerfully, particularly in light of contemporary concerns about climate change and the shared global experiences of the COVID-19 pandemic. The book’s enduring impact lies in its ability to evoke empathy and provoke thought about humanity’s vulnerability and capacity for adaptation in the face of unprecedented challenges.

The Prince and the Dressmaker by Jen Wang

Jen Wang’s The Prince and the Dressmaker, a critically acclaimed graphic novel published in 2018, has garnered significant recognition for its exquisite artistry and its heartwarming exploration of identity, love, and societal expectations. The story unfolds in a fairytale setting, focusing on Prince Sebastian, who grapples with the pressure to marry and secure the succession of his kingdom. Unbeknownst to his parents and the court, Sebastian harbors a secret passion: he secretly lives a double life as the glamorous Lady Chrystallia, a celebrated figure in Parisian society, thanks to the brilliant designs of his dressmaker, Frances.

Frances is the sole confidante of Sebastian’s true desires and aspirations. The narrative beautifully chronicles their evolving relationship as Sebastian grapples with the courage to reveal his authentic self to the world. The graphic novel is lauded for its vibrant and expressive illustrations, its nuanced character development, and its sensitive portrayal of gender fluidity and LGBTQ+ themes. The Prince and the Dressmaker has been widely praised for its inclusivity and its uplifting message about embracing one’s true identity, earning it a prominent place on "Best of the Century So Far: Comics" lists.

The Red Palace by June Hur

June Hur has carved a niche for herself in young adult literature by crafting immersive and compelling historical mysteries, and The Red Palace, published in 2024, exemplifies this expertise. Set in 1758 Korea, the novel introduces Hyeon, an ambitious 18-year-old illegitimate daughter who has secured a position as a palace nurse through hard work and a touch of good fortune. Her primary goal is to maintain her position and, perhaps, earn the elusive approval of her father.

Hyeon’s carefully constructed life is thrown into turmoil when four women are murdered within the palace walls in a single night. When her close friend and mentor is identified as the prime suspect, Hyeon becomes determined to uncover the truth and clear her mentor’s name. Her investigation leads her to a young police inspector, and together they navigate the treacherous political landscape of the Joseon Dynasty, uncovering secrets that may even implicate the Crown Prince. Hur’s work is celebrated for its meticulous historical detail, its atmospheric settings, and its ability to weave intricate plots with engaging character arcs. The Red Palace showcases her skill in transporting readers to different eras and cultures while delivering suspenseful and thought-provoking narratives.

Sadie by Courtney Summers

Courtney Summers’ Sadie, published in 2018, employs a unique dual-narrative structure to deliver a powerful and unflinching revenge thriller. The novel alternates between the perspective of West McCray, a host of a popular true-crime podcast, and the immediate experiences of Sadie. West is investigating the disappearance of Sadie, a young woman from a small, impoverished town who has gone missing following the death of her younger sister, Mattie. As West attempts to piece together the events, the narrative shifts to Sadie’s first-person account, detailing her determined pursuit of the individual she believes is responsible for her sister’s murder.

The novel is lauded for its raw emotional honesty, its complex portrayal of trauma and survival, and its gripping plot. The alternating perspectives create a sense of urgency and suspense, drawing readers into both West’s journalistic investigation and Sadie’s desperate quest for justice. Sadie is praised for its unflinching examination of societal neglect, the cycle of violence, and the resilience of the human spirit. Its innovative structure and profound thematic depth have solidified its place as a significant work in contemporary young adult literature.

SHOUT by Laurie Halse Anderson

Laurie Halse Anderson, a veteran author renowned for her groundbreaking work Speak (1999), continues to champion young voices and advocate for survivors with her powerful memoir in verse, SHOUT, released in 2019. This deeply personal work chronicles Anderson’s own experiences as a survivor, exploring themes of womanhood, activism, intellectual freedom, and the pursuit of personal growth. The book is characterized by its raw honesty, alternating between moments of profound anger, heartfelt hope, sorrow, and unwavering strength.

SHOUT is intentionally crafted as a "shout," not a whisper, aiming to amplify the voices of survivors and inspire collective action. The use of verse lends a lyrical and impactful quality to Anderson’s narrative, making it both accessible and emotionally resonant. The book serves as a testament to the power of storytelling in healing and advocacy, reinforcing Anderson’s long-standing commitment to empowering young people and fostering a more just and equitable world. Her consistent output of significant YA literature solidifies her status as a literary icon.

Vincent and Theo: The Van Gogh Brothers by Deborah Heiligman

Deborah Heiligman, a distinguished author of young adult nonfiction, has consistently produced works that illuminate complex historical figures and events with compelling narratives. Vincent and Theo: The Van Gogh Brothers, published in 2019, stands out for its intimate exploration of the profound and often turbulent relationship between the iconic artist Vincent van Gogh and his devoted brother, Theo. The book delves into their lifelong bond, marked by periods of intense closeness and profound misunderstanding.

What distinguishes this biography is its innovative presentation. Heiligman crafts the narrative as a "gallery" for readers to explore, incorporating letters, artwork, and historical context to provide a multi-faceted perspective on their lives and the artistic movements of their time. This unique approach allows readers to engage with the material on a deeper level, appreciating the complexities of their sibling relationship and the artistic genius that defined Vincent. Heiligman’s ability to render historical figures relatable and engaging for a young adult audience is a testament to her skill as a nonfiction writer, making Vincent and Theo a significant contribution to the genre.

Broader Impact and Ongoing Discourse

The ongoing conversation surrounding the "Best of the Century So Far" lists, including the consideration of these near-misses, underscores the dynamic and subjective nature of literary canonization. These lists, while valuable as curated guides, are not exhaustive pronouncements but rather starting points for deeper engagement with literature. The continued discussion and celebration of influential young adult titles, both those that make official lists and those that are highlighted for their near inclusion, are vital for fostering a vibrant and evolving literary culture. As the century progresses, the YA genre continues to flourish, promising an ever-expanding array of groundbreaking works that will undoubtedly shape future discussions and critical analyses.